About Us

The Pilates Garage began the way the best things often do — organically, in an unexpected space. Twenty-five years ago, Margi Douglas opened her first studio beneath a Brooklyn brownstone, in what had once been a carriage house. You entered through a heavy sliding black door, and inside you found something hard to categorize: an industrial loft space where her husband painted in the back and a handful of Pilates machines occupied the front. It wasn't slick or polished — but it had a magnetism. Artists, movers, and curious minds found their way through that door, and many of them stayed, following Margi when the studio eventually moved to its current home at 441 3rd Avenue.

Over the years, the Pilates Garage grew — in size, in reputation, and in depth of practice. Margi's background in Alexander Technique brought a distinctive quality to the teaching, and collaborations with physical therapists expanded the studio's ability to work with injury, rehabilitation, and adaptive movement. Talented teachers joined the community, and through difficult times — including the upheaval of Covid — the studio held steady, thanks in no small part to the dedication of two remarkable managers: Dylan Goodrich, whose early contributions to planning and building the studio's foundation were invaluable, and Hannah Lawrence, who helped keep things running and grounded through the hardest stretch of the pandemic.

The next chapter began when Margi partnered with Theresa Squire, who had already been a devoted and gifted teacher at the Garage for years. Margi and Theresa first met in the theater world — Margi as an actor, Theresa as a highly skilled costume designer — and when both became mothers, they each found themselves drawn more fully into the world of Pilates. Theresa has since developed a deep interest in injury rehabilitation and neuro-Pilates, making her a natural complement to Margi's therapeutic and Alexander-informed approach. Together, they now share the mission of this place: to build a community that is genuinely welcoming to all bodies and all fitness levels — one where the goal isn't just looking better, but understanding and inhabiting your body more fully, from the inside out.

Three years ago, the studio took another step forward with the opening of The Annex, a smaller, intimate space just around the corner on 8th Street. The Annex has expanded what the Pilates Garage can offer — providing additional room for private sessions, Alexander Technique work, and adaptive and rehabilitative movement in a quieter, more focused setting.

The studio today reflects that vision. Teachers range from classical and fitness-focused to therapeutic and adaptive, giving clients the flexibility to find the approach that truly fits them. New teachers are mentored alongside more advanced practitioners, keeping the community alive and evolving. The Alexander Technique work has grown significantly, with Rachael Scheffrin now teaching a popular group class rooted in the teachings of Ann Rodiger of Balance Arts Center in New York City — and the connections between Alexander and Pilates are becoming ever richer. The recent addition of CoreAlign machines — designed for gait training and athletic movement — has opened another exciting bridge: their upright, dynamic nature makes them a natural complement to Alexander work, allowing clients to experience how the ease and awareness cultivated in an Alexander session can translate directly into balance, tone, and confident movement.

Twenty-five years on, the heavy black door is gone — but the spirit behind it isn't. This is still a place where serious movement meets genuine curiosity, and where every body is welcome.